| Sound News | Press Releases | Archives | Week In Review | Editorials | Articles |
| Reviews | Benchmarks | Interviews | FAQs |Files & Drivers |
| Early Impressions | Game Guide | Search | Links | Forum | Contacts | ADS |



title_3dss.gif (30276 bytes)
dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)

Mark Muschett puts Klipsch's new THX certified 4.1 speaker system to the test

dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)

Please support 3DsoundSurge by visiting our sponsors
dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)
dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)

reviews.gif (6840 bytes)

titleshot2.jpg (4632 bytes) - Mark Muschett - Last updated May 21, 2000

Review Index:

Performance:

If you had read my early impressions, you will already know that I was fairly impressed with the system.

The 400 watts are divided 5 ways, with 60 to each satellite and 160 to the subwoofer. The two-way satellites are precise, which is probably a result of the Micro Tractrix horn mounted dome tweeter / long throw midbass driver combination. The subwoofer is simply incredible and consists of dual side-firing active 6.5" long throw drivers and a flared tuned port. Bass response according to specifications goes down to 29 Hz which is lower than any other multimedia speakers we have tested and a frequency test using the same audio test CD we use on all our speaker reviews shows it gets down there with flying colours. I was told that the subwoofer crosses over to the sats at around the 150 Hz level.  My frequency test CD shows that the sub is handling frequencies up to 200 Hz (which is the highest discrete level on my test CD), which is what I would expect with a 150 Hz crossover.

With 400 watts of power you certainly will expect them to be loud and that’s just what they are putting out up to 110 dB peak sound pressure level (SPL) according to the specifications. A Decibel (dB) is a unit of measurement commonly used for intensities of sound or sound pressure. This is a logarithmic unit defined so that an increase of 1 dB represents multiplication in sound level or signal power of 1.258.

Using a sound level meter I was able to confirm their impressive loudness with more than a simple "they are loud" statement. The sound pressure meter was set on a tripod mount at exactly my normal head position when I am at the PC. This means 3 feet away from the front speakers and 3 feet from the rear speakers. I also did a test when the front speakers and subwoofer are 6 feet away and the rear speakers about 3 feet away, more typical movie set-up (9 & 3 would have been better but I don't have a deep enough test room.  I used four different wav files,  the main two being a 1 kHz test tone and pink noise, both of which are generally accepted for testing sound pressure levels.   In addition I have carried tests using  a wav file from the Aureal wavetracing demo called dx71.wav and a second from Creative’s original EAX demo called dog.wav just because that's how I started testing but all future level testing will only use the 1 kHz and pink noise test.  If you are interested you can grab a 348 KB zip file of these two files. These files emphasize different frequencies and I did this to gauge the variation in sensitivity of the sound level meter to different frequencies. Both files were played back using Sensaura’s 3D Player (nothing like mixing and matching).

The 1 kHz test tone was taken from the same audio test CD that I tested the subwoofer response with but was converted to an MP3 and played back with Winamp to allow for standardized testing between different testers.  The pink noise was generated using the demo version of Cool Edit from Syntrillium.  All tests were done on a Sound Blaster Live using analog outputs for consistency.   The results of those tests are summarized in the second and third tables below.   

For reference I compared the volume to the very good Cambridge Soundworks FPS2000 digital system at full power to the Promedia’s at full power using the two wav files and across a range of power levels using the 1 kHz test tone and the pink noise. The FPS 2000 put out a peak SPL of 97 dB using dx71.wav, 86 dB peak SPL using dog.wav, 98 dB using the 1 kHz test tone and  97 dB for the pink noise where as the Promedia’s put out a peak SPL of 104 dB, 99 dB, 106 dB and 105 dB  respectively. Looking back to the logarithmic nature of a dB this means that at full volume in the 3 & 3 configuration noted below the Promedia’s have a sound level or signal power 6.4 times stronger when playing the 1 kHz test tone and when playing the pink noise.    This however does not correspond directly to the perception of loudness.    We generally perceive loudness to be doubled when the intensity increases by a factor of 10. This corresponds to a 10 dB increase which for example means that dog.wav is perceived to be a bit more than twice as loud on the ProMedias as on the FPS2000s.

This table summarizes the recorded numbers for the Promedia v.2-400s using dx71.wav at a range of settings:

Percent of Power

dx71.wav

25

86.0 dB

33

89.5 dB

50

96.0 dB

75

102 dB

100

104 dB


1 kHz test tone - no subwoofer response at this frequency so this is a test of satellite output alone.

Distance to front (and sub)/rear speakers

Promedia

FPS2000

3 feet

106 dB

98 dB

6 feet and 3 feet

106 dB

94 dB

6 feet and rear off

104 dB

92 dB


Pink Noise - this is a test of combined subwoofer and satellite response.

Distance to front (and sub)/rear speakers

Promedia

FPS2000

3 feet

105 dB

97 dB

6 feet and 3 feet

104 dB

94 dB

6 feet and rear off

101 dB

93 dB


DVD Scene in Soldier - this is a multi-frequency test with emphasis on low end.

Distance to front (and sub)/rear speakers

Promedia

FPS2000

6 feet and 3 feet

106 dB

94 dB


Note:  All of these numbers were done using the original preamp that was shipping with the ProMedia at the time of the original review. A new gain modified preamp is now shipping with all units which will affect these number but based on our own testing it does not affect the maximum "useable" performance - for updated performance numbers you can look at either our ProMedia vs. Crossfire comparison article or our Boston Acoustics BA4800 review.

For a little more perspective, a typical conversation is 65 dB, a loud orchestra is 80 dB, unsafe levels start at 90 dB, thunder is around 109 dB, a rock concert is 110 dB and the pain threshold is around 130 dB. U.S. Department of Labor regulations set permissible noise exposure to 105 dB at no more than 1 hour per day! The bottom line is the Promedia’s are by far the loudest multimedia speakers I have ever heard, so loud that they can hurt my ears and not distort! I am not saying they are distortion proof though as heavy bass at very high volumes can cause the subwoofer to "burp", but in my testing I watched an entire DVD movie at 75 percent power and explosions in the movie were peaking at over 100 dB with nary a trace of distortion to my ears!

Back to the detailed overview and installation

On to sound quality testing and final summary

Speaker Reviews

Abit SP50

Altec Lansing ACS 56

Altec Lansing ACS 54

Altec Lansing ADA880 Dolby Digital

Altec Lansing ATP3

Boston Acoustics BA4800

Boston Acoustics BA7500

Cambridge Soundworks FPS1000

Cambridge SoundWorks FPS2000 digital

Cambridge SoundWorks 2.1 Digital

Cambridge SoundWorks DeskTop Theater 5.1 DTT2500

Cambridge SoundWorks DeskTop Theater 5.1 DTT3500

Cambridge SoundWorks MegaWorks 510D

Diamond Audio Technology ProMedia 3205

Klipsch ProMedia 2.1

Klipsch ProMedia 4.1

Klipsch ProMedia 5.1 Initial Review

Labtec APX 4620 Review

Labtec Edge-418 Flat Panel

Labtec's LCS-2514

Logitech SoundMan Xtrusio DSR-100

Logitech Z-560 Initial Review

MidiLand MLi-490

MidiLand S4-7100

MidiLand S4-7100 Plus

Monsoon MM-1000

Monsoon MM-2000

Philips MMS305 4.1 Initial Review

Polk Audio AMR-150

Polk Audio AMR-130

Videologic Sirocco

Videologic Sirocco Pro

Videologic DigiTheatre 5.1

VideoLogic DigiTheatre DTS

Videologic Sirocco Crossfire

Yamaha TSS1 Dolby Digital / DTS 5.1

Sirocco Crossfire vs ProMedia v.2-400

Evergreen RumbleFX force feedback headphones

Jazz Speakers DE-005/DE-006 Digital Audio Decoders

MidiLand ADS-2000

Boostaroo Headphone Amplifier / Splitter

Spectrum Research Theater 2000

Qsound UltraQ

More reviews

dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)

3dss_small.gif (2549 bytes)All content, design and work is © 2001 - 3D Sound Surge Please respect the copyrights of the articles and writers herein. All copyrights are enforced by 3DSS.  
View the 3DsoundSurge Privacy Statement

dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)